Why do nurses have such little decision-making power in countries where they drive the healthcare system?
They have huge responsibility, but little authority.
I’m one of almost 5 000 nurse-midwives in the mountain kingdom of Lesotho. We serve a country of just over two million people. Nurse-midwives make up 80% of my country’s health workers, a 2018 Nurse Education in Practice study found.
We’re on the frontline – literally.
The 4 800 of us make sure 333 000 people with HIV get the services they need. This translates to providing antiretroviral treatment to just over half of our country’s HIV-infected adults, according to Lesotho’s 2014 health and demographic survey.
It’s a daunting task, especially when you consider how hard hit Lesotho is by HIV and tuberculosis. We’re the country with the second-highest HIV infection rate in the world. Data published by UNAids in 2017 reveal that one out of four adults have contracted the virus.
Despite the country’s extensive health problems, it doesn’t have a single medical school. All our doctors had been trained elsewhere. For every one physician in my country, there are about 20 nurses, a 2010 assessment by the organisation Health Systems has shown.
As a result, nurse-midwives single-handedly manage Lesotho’s primary healthcare clinics, particularly in rural areas, where about three-quarters of Basotho people live.
You might assume, then, that veteran nurses like me can rest easy, if not celebrate what should be an exalted status. That all who are poised to graduate from the country’s six nurse-midwifery institutions can anticipate the security of a career that offers ample respect and remuneration.
But in a country with a nurse-led healthcare system, we lead in action only.
Let me explain.
Nurses in Lesotho run the show. But they have little power to give their patients the care they require. (Reuters/James Akena)
We prescribe and monitor the treatment for people with HIV. Yet we’re not allowed to switch their treatment regimens.
When patients become resistant to first-line antiretroviral treatment, they have to move on to another set of drugs, known as second-line treatment. But only doctors can authorise this.
Because this process is centralised, and can only happen at district level, it means clients have to book hospital appointments with a doctor. Such trips can be distant, time-consuming and expensive.
As a result, some HIV-positive clients in need of second-line treatment never access it.
A case in point is Mrs Thabo*, who lives in Makoabating village in the Thaba-Tseka district, 280km east of the country’s capital, Maseru. She’s a 45-year-old widow with four children under the age of 10. For healthcare, Mrs Thabo goes to Sehonghong health centre. It’s about 10km from her home.
If she needs to switch HIV treatment, she would be referred to Paray Mission Hospital. She would have to travel more than 200km to get there.
Who would she leave her children with? Should she spend the little amount of money she has to pay for her transport to Paray or buy food for her children?
If we as nurses want more authority, we need to advocate for law changes. Nursing in my country is guided by the Lesotho Nursing Act of 1998. It no longer addresses the current scope of nursing and midwifery practice. The 1998 Nursing Act was revised in 2016 and became the Lesotho Nursing and Midwifery Act of 2016, which gives nurses more authority. But it hasn’t yet been in enacted by Parliament.
But we also need to change how we learn to nurse.
Until relatively recently, nursing and midwifery students received very little real-world exposure to the rural clinics and hospitals where most are deployed.
A nurse working autonomously in a far-flung clinic – which is the norm – doesn’t have the luxury to be “just a nurse”, because she’s also a de facto pharmacist and doctor. Students who are trained primarily in large, urban hospitals – where doctors issue the orders – serve in auxiliary roles at the expense of learning to lead.
As a student in the 1980s, I had the good fortune to receive midwifery training in a very remote facility. Some of my clients arrived on horseback. We relied on roja-roja (two-way radios) to communicate with other facilities.
One night, I was assisting a pregnant woman who gave birth normally. But after the birth, her tummy remained very big. Further examination revealed another baby — an undiagnosed twin whose sideways presentation required a procedure to rotate the baby to a head-first position.
I had been taught in theory how to do this, but had never actually done it. Luckily for me, the nurse supervisor that night offered calm assistance, allowing me to step to the forefront. I learned the procedure, and I learned how it felt to lead. Having led this one time left me eager for opportunities to lead again.
Read how nurses in Mozambique have taken responsibility for the country's shortage of doctors.
A community placement programme for nurses, which started in 2011, is trying to do just that: giving students enough exposure to practicing nursing in remote settings. The programme is run by the ministry of health, the Christian Health Association of Lesotho and Jhpiego, where I work.
Between April 2013 and June 2014, we conducted a study to measure the impact of primary healthcare clinical placements on students and preceptors or supervisors. The results, published in the journal Nurse Education and Practice in January, show that these placements helped to boost the confidence and competence of nursing and midwifery students.
These factors will likely aid their transition into the workforce and perhaps increase the likelihood for the young professionals to accept deployment to these areas postgraduation.
I sense the pendulum swinging back to nursing education practices of decades ago.
Elizabeth Iro’s recent appointment as the first chief nursing officer at the World Health Organisation marked the most monumental leap ever in terms of nursing leadership for the profession.
It inspired hope that some day a Lesotho nurse may loom as large on the world stage as nurses do in our home country.
When he appointed Iro, director general Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus said: “Nurses play a critical role, not only in delivering healthcare to millions around the world, but also in transforming health policies, promoting health in communities, and supporting patients and families.”
That is a forward-thinking vision of global healthcare that nurse leaders everywhere can really get behind.
*Not her real name
Semakaleng Phafoli, PhD, is a senior technical advisor for Jhpiego, an international nonprofit health organisation affiliated with Johns Hopkins University. She is a nurse-midwife with more than 14 years of experience as a nursing and midwifery educator in academic institutions in Lesotho.
Have something to say? Tweet or Facebook us on @Bhekisisa_MG
'I would buy the HIV home test because it's easier than being disrespected by nurses'
In good hands: Mozambique's nurses take up the scalpel for safer births
Doctors pass the scalpel to nurses in the quest for safer births
Fed-up NHI doctors say they are nothing more than glorified nurses
Curing a sick system: Doctors and nurses must speak out for patients and themselves
Comment: Eastern Cape, heal thy nurses
When a few months of treatment costs as much as a house, some patients are taking their lives and the law into their own hands to survive.
One in four people carry this potentially deadly bug? Now a new shorter treatment can prevent it from making you sick.
Recent national and Gauteng memos demanding all foreign patients pay in full for services likely fell foul of the law.
Bhekisisa means "to scrutinise" in Zulu
In South Africa, Zulu patients who would like to be thoroughly assessed by a doctor, would ask the physician to "bhekisisa" them.