By the time it was done, the Life Esidimeni tragedy had claimed four times the number that died in the first massacre in the new democratic South Africa.
In 2015, Gauteng health MEC Qedani Mahlangu announced the province would terminate a decades-old contact with the private hospital group Life Esidimeni to provide state-subsidised care for about 1 700 mental health patients. Many of these patients had spent most of their lives in institutions, their families unable to manage the high level of care they needed at home.
But the contract, Mahlangu argued, had become too expensive.
Gauteng health officials decided these patients could now be sent home, to other state facilities or community-based NGOs. Patient families, civil society and professional bodies cautioned that patients were not well enough to go home and NGOs were ill-equipped.
The transfers went ahead anyway, and ultimately at least 144 mental health patients lost their lives after being placed in state facilities and NGOs that were eventually found to be unlicensed.
In the aftermath of a damning ombud report, 134 patient families agreed to take part in a historic arbitration to allow the Gauteng health department to avoid litigation and to promote healing. Former Deputy Chief Justice Dikgang Moseneke presided over the 44 days of hearings during which officials, families, NGO owners and experts testified as to what led to the fatal decision to relocate patients and what happened after.
To mark the one-year anniversary of the start of the Life Esidimeni arbitration, Bhekisisa has obtained the full official transcripts of the hearings, which are available for download below.
44 days of testimonies, dozens of witnesses and more than one hundred deaths. Read our summaries and download the transcripts. (Jabu Kumalo, Gallo)
Health Ombud Malegapuru Makgoba goes into detail about his investigation and report into the 144 deaths.
Project manager Levy Mosenogi reveals what happened when he tried to stop the removals and how former Gauteng health MEC Qedani Mahlangu accused him of being a spokesperson for the Life Esidimeni hospital group.
National health department director general Precious Matsoso testifies that the Gauteng health department did not inform the national government of its plans to relocate patients.
Director general in the Office of the Gauteng Premier, Phindile Baleni tells the arbitration that the Human Rights Commission is also investigating the Life Esidimeni deaths.
Former acting head of the Gauteng health department Ernest Kenoshi reveals all the officials facing disciplinary action for their role in the project.
Social worker at the Cullinan Care Rehabilitation Centre outside Pretoria Daphne Ndhlovu at discloses that the facility took in patients that it was not typically mandated to care for. The facility not only took in Life Esidimeni patients but transferred some of its own patients to unlicensed facilities operating on its grounds to accommodate them.
It’s been a year since the Life Esidimeni arbitration. (Andronica Nedzamba)
Owner of the deadly Precious Angels NGO Ethel Ncube admits that she was not qualified to look after mental health patients and blames the department of health for not supporting her when she needed funds to buy patients food.
Life Esidimeni managing director Morgan Mkhatshwa reveals that in 2007 young children were removed from the private healthcare facility and were sent to NGOs. Some of the children died of hunger, malnutrition and dehydration. These were also causes of death among some of the 144 Life Esidimeni patients who later died between 2015 and 2016.
He also disclosed that Life Esidimeni offered the Gauteng department of health the option to buy their facilities, but the department did not consider the offer.
Father of deceased mental health patient Billy Maboe, Joseph Maboe, tells the arbitration that patients were transported in trucks like cattle from Life Esidimeni facilities to NGOs.
When Boitumelo Magena’s family visited her mother at the Soweto-based NGO Takalani, she describes how it was impossible to recognise her because she had lost so much weight.
Life Esidimeni family committee member Christine Nxumalo voices the pain she and other family members went through as they tried to trace Life Esidimeni patients after they were removed from private facilities. Some families spent months trying to locate loved ones because the move was poorly organised.
Ntombifuthi Dhladhla describes the gruesome details of finding her brother’s gravely decomposed body at a mortuary. Some families were only notified of patient deaths weeks after they had passed. Dhladhla was unable to wash or dress her brother’s body before burial because of the state of his body.
Then, Lucas Mogwerane goes into details of how his brother died within two weeks of being discharged from Life Esidimeni and placed in the care of the Rebafeni NGO. The organisation later confessed to Mogwerane that there was no food for patients.
Lucas Mogwerane’s brother died shortly after being transferred to an NGO that had no food for patients. (Andronica Nedzamba)
South African Police Services major general Charles Johnson headed up the special task team inquiry into the deaths. He tells the arbitration that the Gauteng department of health’s delay in supplying the police with documents delayed the investigation. The task team subsequently resorted to court action to get necessary documents.
Chairperson of the Gauteng Mental Health Review Board Dumi Masondo admits she didn’t understand her duties as part of her role on the legally-mandated oversight body meant to protect patient rights. She also didn’t know she had the power to veto the MEC of health and director of mental health on issues about mental health patients.
Anchor Life NGO owner Dorothy Franks admits using patient grants to run the organisation. She also says she collected these grants for four months after the government shut down her NGO. Anchor Life never had a license to house mental health patients on the ground of the Cullinan Care and Rehabilitation Centre.
Details of the first mental health patient who died are revealed. Deborah Petla’s post-mortem found that she had died with brown paper and plastic bags in her stomach. Her mother, Maria, says this is evidence of how hungry her daughter was. She says that her daughter was locked in a room where files were kept.
Jabulile Hlatswayo testifies that former head of Gauteng mental health services Makgabo Manamela came to her home on the eve of her stepson Sizwe’s funeral and asked her for a post-mortem. Jabulile was notified of SIzwe’s death weeks after it happened and was never contacted by the Cullinan Care Rehabilitation Centre whose staff said they never had a listed next of kin for Sizwe.
The health ombud reveals newly discovered deaths.
At least 144 mental health users died after being transferred from Life Esidimeni.
Clinical psychologist Coralie Trotter says that it is her professional opinion that mental health patients were tortured in NGOs. She says conditions in NGOs were similar to those associated with concentration camps.
Nursing manager at Cullinan Care and Rehabilitation Centre, Dikeledi Manaka says only 10 patients were supposed to be relocated to the facility, but they were forced to take 26.
Manaka, admits that the facility was forced to take in more patients than it could safely house.
Patient family member Lillian Mpofu says she witnessed patients being served small portions of plain rice.
The former head of Gauteng mental health services Makgabo Manamela tells of how several Life Esidimeni patients died at one NGO before the government gave them money to feed and cloth patients.
Patient family member Andrew Peterson explains how he was blindsided by the announcement of Life Esidimeni’s closure — at an annual Christmas party over a loudspeaker.
Patient family member Moelo Mofokeng says she thinks the Gauteng health department knew that NGOs were not ready to receive patients and that they might die as a result before the moved patients.
Cullinan Care and Rehabilitation Centre unit manager, Alfred Rasidzoge, is questioned about why a Life Esidimeni patient’s body decomposed while in the facility’s mortuary.
The former head of Gauteng mental health services Makgabo Manamela continues with her testimony and sheds new light on internal discussions around the removal of Life Esidimeni patients.
Manamela recounts how she was aware that there were NGOs patients were moved to organisations had never cared for mental health care users.
Head of Gauteng mental health services Makgabo Manamela was aware some NGOs had no experience caring for mental health patients. (Andronica Nedzamba)
In day three of her testimony, Manamela reads an autopsy report that indicates a former Life Esidimeni patient died of severe dehydration. Evidence was found that patients did not receive proper care at NGOs. Some were not given food and water.
Mamelodi Regional Hospital mortuary service manager Daniel Buda testifies that the body of former Life Esidimeni patient Joseph Gemede came in smelling and in an advanced state of decomposition from Cullinan Care and Rehabilitation Centre.
Longiswa Victoria Nomzibanzi family member of mental healthcare user, Mkanyisele, explains that her brother was operated on without her consent.
Nompilo Nkosi whose brother Sizwe is autistic said she was told by Manamela that her brother would be moving to Cullinan Care and Rehabilitation Centre and that the facility was like a “5-star hotel”.
Joseph Ngwenya’s son, also a mental health patient, was moved without him knowing to an unknown location. When Ngwenya found him at a mental healthcare facility, he didn’t recognise his son who was thinner than before and smelled like he had soiled himself.
Lesego Baloyi talks of her sister Julia Malinzwi Hlatle who survived a typhoid outbreak at Takalani, a Soweto NGO.
Nomsa Radebe testifies about her brother Mandla David Radebe who was transferred to Bophelong without her knowledge. When she eventually found him, he pleaded with her to take him with her.
Modianeane Abraham Maditsi’s niece, Kgotso Maditsi, is a mental health patient. When Maditsi visited her at the Takalani NGO, he took her home for fear that she would die there.
The former head of Gauteng health department Barney Selebano says Mahlangu was responsible for pressurising NGOs to take more patients than they should, resulting in the department contracting unequipped organisations.
Selebano testifies saying he was scared of Mahlangu.
On the third day of his testimony, Selebano talks about what he thinks should have happened in hindsight. “I wish I could have stopped this project [in its] tracks,” he says.
Nomvula Nonjabe describes how her sister Kajakazi Nonjabe was moved from a Life Esidimeni facility to the NGO Goetsi Modimo where the walls were made of concrete slabs normally used for fences.
Gauteng health deputy director of mental health Hanna Jakobus says she raised concerns about the NGOs not being ready for patients but participated in the Life Esidimeni transfer nonetheless.
Jakobus testifies once again, this time taking responsibility as the person in charge of coordinating mental health NGOs.
University of the Witwatersrand head of bioethics and health law Ames Dhai talks on healthcare professionals’ oaths and ethical obligations.
Former Gauteng health MEC Mahlangu says she did not participate in the arbitration in November and December because she was studying at the London School of Business and Finance. After a public outcry over Mahlangu’s absence, the school subsequently suspends her.
When asked whether she agrees that the decision to terminate the Life Esidimeni contract resulted in the deaths of 143 patients, Mahlangu said, “I am not a medical doctor or forensic expert, so I don’t know who died of what.”
Mahlangu says she cannot carry the personal blame for Life Esidimeni as she is just an elected official.
Psychiatrist Chris Grobler is a professor at Walter Sisulu University and a member of the South African Society of Psychiatrists (SASOP), which tried to stop the relocation of Life Esidimeni patients. He testifies that if those involved in the Life Esidimeni transfer asked logical questions about the level of care people needed, death would have been foreseen.
Gauteng MEC for finance Barbara Creecy argues there is no evidence to support that the Life Esidimeni contract was terminated to save money despite three officials stating it as a cause for the termination.
Gauteng premier David Makhura explains that he did not know Life Esidimeni patients were transferred to NGOs.
Makhura argues that he was not shown a plan that stated that patients would be discharged to NGOs.
Gauteng Health MEC Gwen Ramkgopa, who took over for Mahlangu following her resignation, speaks of the lessons she has learned from Mahlangu’s time in office.
Minister of health Aaron Motsoaledi breaks down in tears while testifying and explains that under the law, he has limited authority over MECs.
Closing arguments are heard from advocates representing families and patients, namely the public interest law organisations Section27 and Legal Aid as well as trade union Solidarity’s social assistance arm Helping Hands. The trio request about R1.7-million per family — or R1.5-million in compensation for Constitutional damages and an additional 200 000 for trauma counselling.
People can claim Constitutional damages when a government official has violated their Constitutional rights such as the right to health, life or equality. To successfully claim for such damages advocates must show that there is no alternative way to obtain redress for human right violations under common law.
In closing arguments, state advocate Tebogo Hutamo argues that families of the deceased family members are not entitled to Constitutional compensation. The state believes that they did not breach any rights of family members.
The Gauteng government is ordered to pay each of the 135 Life Esidimeni claimants involved in the arbitration R1-million in Constitutional damages as “appropriate relief and compensation for the government’s unjustifiable and reckless breaches” of six sections of the Constitution and “multiple contraventions” of the National Health Act and Mental Health Care Act.
It also has to pay the families of patients who died R20 000 to cover funeral costs of loved ones and R180 000 for shock and psychological trauma.
Nelisiwe Msomi was a health reporter at Bhekisisa. She holds a bachelors degree in journalism from the University of Johannesburg.
She is interested in seeing government policies go beyond paper and boardrooms, and see how they translate into action on the ground.
At Bhekisisa, Msomi sniffs around studies for solutions that can make access to healthcare better and efficient. If she is not writing the news, she is reading it.
Roxy de Villiers is Bhekisisa's social media content producer and engagement officer.
She crafts Bhekisisa's social media and assists with website and online content. She helps organise media trainings, policy dialogues and you might not know it but she has probably been the one speaking to you if you've had a request or question about Bhekisisa.
De Villiers believes the personal is political and has an interest in reporting on queer health issues.
She honed her skills in community media and has also worked with the Rosebank-based community radio station, Radio Today, as a guest newsreader.
