A proposed Bill by the African Christian Democratic Party could endanger legal abortions in South Africa, doctors have warned.
The ACDP’s amendment to the 1996 Choice on Termination of Pregnancy Act would require women to undergo ultrasound scans. Healthcare workers would be legally mandated to affix scan photographs of the fetus to a patient’s consent form before she signed it.
The Bill’s ultrasound requirement is not only likely to drive women into the hands of illegal abortionists, it is also manipulative, says Indira Govender, the KwaZulu-Natal representative of the Rural Doctors Association of Southern Africa.
Ultrasound machines, and the healthcare workers trained to use them, are often only found at major hospitals and not at clinics, which is where most people seek out care, she says.
Unable to have the scans they need for legal abortions, women could be forced into dangerous backstreet operations: "[Abortionists] don’t care about the consequences – they are basically drug dealers in the community," Govender says.
And, she maintains, forcing people to look at ultrasounds before terminating a pregnancy is nothing more than an orchestrated "guilt trip".
"These are tactics that are used in the United States by the anti-abortion groups. They try to make women second-guess their choices through guilt and shame by showing them pictures of a fetus."
Rural, under-resourced people will pay the highest priceBut ACDP MP Cheryllyn Dudley argues that the proposed amendment would ensure that women make informed choices about having an abortion.
Currently, South African law allows women to choose whether they would like pre-abortion counselling, explains the Mpumalanga health department’s obstetrics and gynaecology specialist, Eddie Mhlanga.
He says health workers shouldn’t try to sway a person’s choice when they counsel a woman, but should instead talk about possible complications and alternatives.
"[As a health worker], you give them information so that they can make an informed choice, but they have already made the choice," he says.
Mhlanga is widely credited with helping to pass the 1996 Act that increased access to legal abortions. He says the ACDP opposed the Act’s introduction then and is now threatening to take the country back to the days when women – particularly poor and black women – died in droves from illegal abortions.
"The woman makes the decision according to her own circumstances. We should not be placing further barriers [that will take us] back to the apartheid era, where African women or poor women who could not afford private doctors … were excluded. We saw quite a large number of those women dying from the complications of backstreet abortions," he recalls.
Prior to 1996, legal abortions could only be carried out in cases of rape, incest or when the mother’s health was at stake. All legal abortions had to be approved by three doctors and most were limited to white women, according to a 2003 article published in the British Medical Bulletin.
Says Mhlanga: "I am one of seven obstetricians in the public service in Mpumalanga. I work in the rural areas in Mpumalanga. Women in under-resourced areas are the ones to whom they [the ACDP] want to deny access to [abortions]."
Abortion-related deaths fell by 90% in less than a decade after the 1996 Act was introduced, researchers pointed out in the South African Medical Journal in 2005. Today, the World Health Organisation recognises the provision of safe, legal abortions as a way to curb maternal deaths.
Ultrasound machines and the workers who operate them are a scarce commodity in the public sector (Gallo)
The ACDP’s proposal would also end a woman’s ability to request an abortion based on socioeconomic grounds after 13 weeks and the right to terminate later-term pregnancies at 20 weeks in cases where, for example, fetuses had severe deformities.
The ACDP argues that a 20-week fetus would be viable, or capable of living outside the womb, and that most medical problems would be fixable. Mhlanga and Govender say that view is not rooted in reality.
"Nowhere in South Africa will one deliver at 20 weeks a fetus and then that fetus survives," says Mhlanga. Govender says although it is possible to correct some birth defects late in pregnancy, this kind of surgical skill is scarce in the country. "You can count the number of paediatric surgeons on your one hand that are available in the public sector."
But Dudley maintains that the Bill reflects public opinion: "A significant number of people feel that the original legislation was forced on South Africans. They don’t actually feel that they had any part in bringing it into being."
Although some small studies have surveyed the attitudes of healthcare workers to abortions, no large-scale research has been done into the views of South Africans.
Public comment on the Bill closed on Wednesday, and it will be debated in Parliament before being opened up for public discussion again. It could take years for the Bill to become law if enacted, Dudley says.
Meanwhile, Mhlanga suggests that, if the ACDP wants to contribute towards reproductive rights, it should educate congregations about family planning and join the fight against illegal abortions.
He says: "We are all pro-life; we are all about life. We prioritise the woman’s life."
[Updated 10 August 2017 3:30 pm This an updated version of an earlier story that incorporated additional comments and analysis]
Have something to say? Tweet or Facebook us on @Bhekisisa_MG
Think people should have access to abortion services? Help us make it happen
When is an abortion legal?
Less than 7% of health facilities nationwide offer abortions - Amnesty International
How to spot an illegal abortion
[From our archives] More married women than singles have abortions
This doctor returned to his home town to live, love and heal.
Work at a non-profit media house? Then you know your job is not just reporting anymore.
Until now, the national and provincial health departments have not been able to say where services are provided. Here's how we found them.
Bhekisisa means "to scrutinise" in Zulu
In South Africa, Zulu patients who would like to be thoroughly assessed by a doctor, would ask the physician to "bhekisisa" them.